JUDGMENTSJUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF April 2012

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Marlon Ho-Tack v British American Insurance Co Ltd
HCVAP 2010/010
Edward, J.A.
Delivered: 16/04/12
Civil Appeal - Insolvent Insurance Company judgment debtor - Appointment of judicial manager - Terms of order and section 61 (4) Insurance Act 2007 staying all actions and other processes against insolvent company - Default judgments obtained before judicial management order - Enforcing judgment after judgment debtor placed under judicial management - Judgment creditor's application for attachment of debts order naming judicial manager as garnishee dismissed by master - Judicial Manager's application to set aside default judgments - whether Judicial Manager's application to be made directly to the Judge and be heard in public - jurisdiction of master to hear the application - Section 217 Insurance Act 2007 - Section 11 Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court Act Cap. 143 - Applicability of English Insolvency Rules and Practice Directions made under the Insolvency Act 1986

GRENADA

Veda Doyle v Agnes Deane
HCVAP 2011/020
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 16/04/12
Civil appeal – Post - judgment interest – Whether post - judgment interest automatically accrued on a judgment debt prior to the enactment of the West Indies Associated States Supreme Court (Grenada) (Amendment) Act, No. 7 of 2009 – Section 11(1) of the West Indies Associated States Supreme Court (Grenada) Act, Cap. 336 – Whether section 11(1) of the Supreme Court Act permits the reception of substantive English law into the law of Grenada

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Rudolph Lewis v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/016
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 16/04/12
Criminal appeal against sentence – Murder – Guilty plea entered at first opportunity – Learned trial judge refusing to accept appellant's guilty plea and entering plea of not guilty instead on his behalf – Whether sentence imposed excessive and reflected early guilty plea – Whether murder being a crime of passion to be taken into account

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS

Ocean Conversion (BVI) Ltd v The Attorney General and The Attorney General v Ocean Conversion (BVI) Ltd
HCVAP 2009/019, 2009/020
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 18/04/12
Civil appeal – Contract – Construction of contracts – Exercise of option – Meaning of the words "prepared to exercise the option" - Failure to tender purchase price – Trade fixtures – Plant expanded beyond originally agreed size – Expenditure encouraged by one party – Expectation of compensation by other party – Estoppel – Unjust enrichment – Illegal contracts – Trial judge's primary findings of fact – Function of appellate court

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Charlesworth Harrigan v Gwendolyn King
Claim No. ANUHCV 2011/0547
Michel, J.
Delivered: 04/04/12

The Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda v Michael Moore
Claim No. ANUHCV 2012/0124
Remy, J.
Delivered: 11/04/12

Michael De Costro v Antigua Masonry Products Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0456
Michel, J.
Delivered: 11/04/12

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Vernon Richards v Jacqueline John
Claim No DOMHCV 0275 of 2001
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 19/04/12

GRENADA
Waynesworth Barrett v The Commissioner of Prisons
Claim No. GDAHCV 2012/0052
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 04/04/12

SAINT LUCIA
Andrew Smith v Clendon Louis
Claim No. SLUHCV 1999/0304
Belle, J.
Delivered: 10/04/12

Modeste Joseph and another v Peter Felicien
Claim No. SLUHCV 2010/0976
Belle, J.
Delivered: 17/04/12

Daphne Lewis v Kevin White and another
Claim No. SLUHCV 2010/0001
Belle, J.
Delivered: 30/04/12

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Timothy St John
High Court Civil Claim No. 423 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 03/04/12

First Caribbean International Bank Ltd v T C Enterprises Ltd et al
High Court Civil Claim No. 422 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 03/04/12

Germison Griffith v Donald Browne
High Court Civil Claim No. 320 of 2011
Thom, J.
Delivered: 12/04/12

Keon Roberts v Lillith Johnson
High Court Civil Claim No. 88 of 2008
Thom, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/04/12

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
The Queen v Wendell Varlack
Case No. 27 of 2011
Joseph Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 23/04/12

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF March 2012

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Igors Kippers et al v Stanford International Bank Ltd
HCVAP 2010/025
Edward, J.A.
Delivered: 14/03/12
Civil Appeal – Procedural appeal – Court's jurisdiction under the International Business Corporation Act Cap. 222 Revised Laws of Antigua and Barbuda (as amended) ("the IBC Act) – section 11 of the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court Act Cap. 143 Revised Laws of Antigua and Barbuda – English Insolvency Act and Rules 1986 (as amended) – English Practice Direction for Distribution of Business of the Companies Court - Winding-up order prohibiting filing of claims without leave of the Court - Whether the Master had jurisdiction to raise the issue and pronounce on the validity of the claims

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Justin Pemberton v The Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Dominica et al
HCVAP 2010/016
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 06/03/12
Civil appeal – Interlocutory appeal – Whether the learned trial judge erred in striking out claim where the appellant's counsel was present in court but the appellant was absent

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Romeo Cannonier v The DPP
HCRAP 2008/002
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/03/12
Criminal appeal against conviction and sentence – Murder – Death penalty – Section 10(1) of Saint Christopher and Nevis Constitution Order 1983 – Whether section 52(2) of the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court (Saint Christopher and Nevis) Act, Cap. 3:11, is unconstitutional and in contravention of section 10 of the Constitution – Whether time should be extended to file notice of appeal where appellant sentenced to death – Whether trial judge erred in refusing to admit alibi evidence – Joint enterprise – Whether trial judge erred in failing to give jury good character direction in relation to propensity when evidence of appellant's good character not adduced by counsel at trial

SAINT LUCIA
C.O. Williams Construction (St. Lucia) Ltd. v Inter-Island Dredging Co. Ltd
HCVAP 2011/017
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 19/03/12
Civil appeal – Application for leave to appeal order of learned judge denying application for extension of time to file defence – Whether application for relief from sanctions must accompany application for extension of time – Rules 26.7, 26.8, 27.8 and 26.9 of the Civil Procedure Rules 2000 – Criteria to be satisfied in making application for extension of time where there is no express sanction for non-compliance with rule, practice direction, statutory provision or court order which prescribes time limit

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Marty Steinberg et al v Swisstor & Co. and another
HCVAP 2011/012
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/03/12
Interlocutory appeal - Whether claim statute barred under the Limitation Act – Qualification for applying for permission to serve proceedings out of the jurisdiction – Extension of time within which to serve a claim form – Limitation Act Cap. 43 of the Virgin Islands – CPR 7.3(3)(b) – CPR 8.13

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
Devcon Ltd v Cap Juluca Properties Ltd
Claim No. AXAHCV 0041/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/03/12

Elise Meyer v Shoal Bay Development Corporation
Claim No. AXAHCV 0028/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/03/12

ANTIGUA
Selwyn Charles v Attorney General
Claim No. ANUHCV 2011/0069
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 02/03/12

Dr. Edmond Mansoor v Eugene Silcott
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0209
Michel, J.
Delivered: 01/03/12

Leroy Silston v Ruthlyn Chambers
Claim No. ANUHPB 2009/0207
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/03/12

Denfield Matthew v Caribbean Golf Lifestyle Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0432
Michel, J.
Delivered: 23/03/12

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Kieron Bryne v Ronald Abraham
DOMHCV 2009/0379
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 02/03/12

Carlisle Jno Baptiste v Island Communication Corporation Ltd et al
DOMHCV 2004/0119
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 09/03/12

Cecelia Robin v The Attorney General and another
Suit No DOMHCV 2012/0058
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 21/03/12

Royal Bank of Canada v Claytus Prevost
DOMHCV 1999/0561
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 09/03/12

Calais Shipholding Co. v Bronwen Energy Trading Ltd
Suit No DOMHCV 2009/0096
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 09/03/12

GRENADA
Damon Dubois v Matthias Jerome et al
Claim No. GDAHCV 2011/0088
Taylor-Alexander,M.
Delivered: 07/03/12

MONTSERRAT

John Ryan et al v Providence Estates Ltd et al
Claim No. MNIHCV 2009/0010
Leigertwood-Octave, J.      
Delivered: 05/03/12

David Brandt v Claude Hogan et al
Claim No. MNIHCV 2001/0031
Leigertwood-Octave, J.      
Delivered: 05/03/12

Montserrat Enterprises v Jone Martinez Gomez
Claim No. MNIHCV 2009/0004
Leigertwood-Octave, J.      
Delivered: 06/03/12

Robert McEwan v The Commissioner of Police and another
Claim No. MNIHCV 2005/0006
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 09/03/12

SAINT LUCIA
Alexandros Evangelidis v Bernadette Auguste
Claim No. SLUHCV 2011/1118
Belle, J.
Delivered: 08/03/12

Desmond Devaux v Richard Johnson and another
Claim No. SLUHCV 2010/0783
Belle, J.
Delivered: 22/03/12

The Queen v Brad Thomas
Claim No. SLUCRD 1590 of 2008
Cumberbatch, J.
Delivered: 13/03/12

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Sherry-Ann Mapp v Lionel Mapp
High Court Civil Claim No. 133 of 2008
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 08/03/12

Cardon Knights v Michael Williams and another
Civil Claim No. 227 of 2007
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 29/03/12

Roy Dabriel v Korina Dabriel
High Court Civil Claim No. 199 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 05/03/12

Karen John v David Debique
High Court Civil Claim No. 359 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 06/03/12

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF February 2012

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA
Francis Monrose v Bank of St Lucia
HCVAP 2011/011
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 13/02/12
Civil Appeal- Part 55 Civil Procedure Rules 2000 (CPR) - Judgment creditor enforcing money judgment- Whether judgment creditor may opt to proceed under Part 55 CPR as distinct from proceeding under the Code of Civil Procedure- Section 2, Money Lending Act- Whether section 2 can be invoked on an application under Part 55 CPR

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Angel Wise Limited v Stark Moly Limited
HCVAP 2010/030
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 13/02/12
Civil Appeal – Loan agreement which was governed by the laws of Singapore - Setting aside of a statutory demand – Whether the trial judge erred in holding that there was no substantial dispute as to the loan agreement on which the statutory demand was based – Section 157 of the Insolvency Act, No. 5 of 2003, Laws of the Virgin Islands

Hilda Elisabeth Stoutt et al v First Bank Puerto Rico
HCVAP 2010/016
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 13/02/12
Banker and customer – Registered land charges – Mother securing business loans of son – Mother elderly, housewifely, and mentally challenged – Mother not obtaining any benefit from loan to knowledge of bank– Duty of bank – Possibility of undue influence – No independent legal advice

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Patrick Lovelace v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/017
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 27/02/12
Criminal appeal against conviction – Murder – Accomplice testifying against the appellant – Corroboration – Lies in the appellant's cautionary statement – Whether Lucas direction was necessary – Failing to permit the defence to refer to evidence from earlier trial – Delay during the currency of the trial – Improper judicial intervention – Whether comments made by the trial judge undermined the credibility of the defence in front of the jury – Discharge of jury – Jury deliberations – Whether directions given by the trial judge to jury at adjournments were inadequate

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA
The Queen v Sylvester Lindsay
Criminal Case No. ANUHCR 2011/0049
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 03/02/12

The Queen v Jay Marie Chin
Criminal Case No. ANUHCR 2011/0031
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 23/02/12

Lester Bird v Winston Baldwin Spencer et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 0185/2009
Remy, J.
Delivered: 21/02/12

ANGUILLA
Craig Wallace et al v Anguillan Development Corporation Ltd
Claim No. AXAHCV 2009/0038
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/02/12

Franklyn Richardson v Egbert Richardson
Claim No. AXAHCV 0029/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/02/12

Sir Emile Gumbs v Sheffield Holdings Ltd
Claim No. AXAHCV 0090/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/02/12

Victoria Romney v Glenford Romney
Suit No. AXAHMT 107 of 1998
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/02/12

Viola Richardson et al v Albert Hughes
Claim No. AXAHCV 0036/2007
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 01/02/12

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Edmund Samuel v Alvin Pascal et al
DOMHCV 2008/0171
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 03/02/12

SAINT LUCIA
Hotel Chocolat Ltd v Maureen Didier et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/1130
Belle, J.
Delivered: 09/02/11

Joseph Rosemond et al v Cicily Rosemond et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0859
Belle, J.
Delivered: 09/02/11

Norina Cooper et al v The Attorney General et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0894
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 14/02/11

Claudius Charles v The Attorney General of Saint Lucia
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0227
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 28/02/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
John Frederick v Kelectric Co. Ltd
High Court Civil Claim No 387/2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/02/12

Leontius Robinson v Edgar Davis
High Court Civil Claim No. 0004 of 2012
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/02/12

Ralph Gonsalves v Matthew Thomas et al
Civil Suit No HCVSVG 2007/0064
Taylor-Alexander, M.
Delivered: 10/02/12

Avaline O'Garro et al v Neil Ross et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2004/329
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 09/02/12

Hermus Cyrus v Christopher Willie
High Court Civil Claim No 232 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 07/02/12

David Richards v Cornelius Ollivierre
High Court Civil Claim No 422 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 13/02/12

Rodney Williams v Rohand De Roche
High Court Civil Claim No 111 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 21/02/12

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
The Queen v Jay Chin
Criminal Case No ANUHCR 2011/0031
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 23/02/12

D v D
BVIHMT 2007/0034
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 08/02/12

Patrick Smith v Lydia Smith
BVIHMT 2006/0028
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 28/02/12
Family Law – Ancillary Relief – Maintenance and custody of children – Interest in matrimonial home. The Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 1995 Sections 44, 47 and 51

Petra Cooper v Peter Cooper
BVIHMT 2011/0044
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 29/02/12
Family Law – Ancillary relief – 1. custody – maintenance for infant child –2. Monies obtained from mortgage given to wife by husband during marriage – whether wife obligated to repay the monies to husband

Lucien Callwood et al v The Registrar of Lands
Claim No BVIHCV 20080142
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 17/02/12
Prescription – Appeal against the Registrar of Lands

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF January 2012

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA
Gregory Knight v 1st Caribbean International Bank
HCVAP 2011/032
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/01/12
Civil appeal – Grant of Power of Attorney by elderly parent to allow access to joint bank account – Injunction granted by judge in court below prohibiting appellant in Claim No. GDAHCV 2011/0467 from acting under Power of Attorney

SAINT LUCIA
Cage St Lucia Ltd et al v The Gaming Authority et al
HCVAP 2011/045
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 23/01/12
Civil appeal – Application to review the decisions of two single judges of the Court of Appeal – Whether the respondent to an application for leave to appeal is entitled to oppose the application – Whether the respondent to an application for leave to appeal may invoke the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal to review the decision of a single judge and consider the merits of the proposed appeal …

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Royal Westminster Investment et al v Nilon Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/034 & HCVAP 2011/001 (Consolidated)
Bennett, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/01/12
Civil appeal – Oral joint venture agreement made in another jurisdiction – Rectification of share register – Section 43 of the BVI Business Companies Act, 2004, Act No. 16 of 2004, Laws of the Virgin Islands – Section 359 of the English Companies Act 1985 …

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA
Carter Smith v Nicolaas Bersma
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0718
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 12/01/12

Overseas Property Bond Management Ltd v Antigua Commercial Bank Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2006/0552
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 27/01/12

Sea Star Ltd v Timothy Dupont-Stinedurf
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0775
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 16/01/12

Robin Darby v LIAT (1974) Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 201F0/0160
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 17/01/12

Antigua & Barbuda Free Trade Union v The Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0568
Remy, J.
Delivered: 25/01/12

Audrey Barratt v Hawksbill Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0343
Remy, J.
Delivered: 25/01/12

Sir Gerald A Watt v The Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0025
Remy, J.
Delivered: 25/01/12

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Aldie Toussaint v Mary Austrie
DOMHCV2003/0186
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 27/01/12

Ronald Green v Petter Saint Jean et al and Maynard Joseph v Roosevelt Skerrit et al [election petition 1]
Dominica High Court Civil Claim Nos. 6 of 2010 & 7 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 10/01/12

Ronald Green v Petter Saint Jean et al and Maynard Joseph v Roosevelt Skerrit et al [election petition 2]
Dominica High Court Civil Claim Nos. 6 of 2010 & 7 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 10/01/12

GRENADA
John Forshaw et al v Eric Williams et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0563
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 17/01/12

Andre Garvey v Grenreal Property Corporation Ltd
Claim No GDAHCV 2010/0157
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 17/01/12

Ashandi Edwards v Rholda Bhola and another
Suit No GDAHCV 2006/0587
Taylor-Alexander, M.
Delivered: 24/01/12

MONTSERRAT
Adrienne Mars et al v Secretary of State et al
Claim No MNIHCV2008/0012
Redhead, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/01/12

Mildred Kirwan v Neville Kirwan
Claim No MNIHCV2011/0007
Redhead, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/01/12

SAINT LUCIA

Church of God Seventh Day Inc. v Hector Mathurin et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2011/1201
Belle, J.
Delivered: 18/01/12

Jada Construction Caribbean Ltd v The Landing Limited
Claim No SLUHCV 2006/0771
Belle, J.
Delivered: 19/01/12

Conrad Charles v The Attorney General
Claim No SLUHCV 2009/0852
Belle, J.
Delivered: 19/01/12

General Aviation Services Ltd et al v Director General of the Eastern Caribbean Civil Aviation Authority et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2011/0584
Belle, J.
Delivered: 25/01/12

Robert Gabriel v Trevor John
Claim No SLUHCV 2011/0210
Taylor-Alexander, M.
Delivered: 17/01/12

Earl Huntley v Rick Wayne et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2005/0543
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 31/01/12

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Eli Williams v Beverly Barnwell
Claim No 166 of 2008
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/01/12

The Director of Public Prosecutions of SVG v Chief Magistrate of SVG
Case No 177 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/01/12

Otto Sam v Tyrone Burke et al
High Court Civil Claim No 399 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 30/01/12

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Dora Scatliffe v Irvin Scatliffe
Claim No BVIHMT 2008/0047
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 03/01/12
Matrimonial proceedings -Divorce -Ancillary Relief -Occupation order-What comprises matrimonial assets-division of matrimonial assets -Equality -non-disclosure by Respondent -Court entitled to draw adverse inferences

Arti Assets Ltd v Sumeries Ltd
Claim No BVIHCV 2011/0139
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 04/01/12

Rosilee Herbert v Attorney General
BVIHCV 2010/0294
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 26/01/12
Equity-Estoppel- Estoppel by representation- Claimant, a Public Officer retired from the Public Service- claimant alleging government represented to her that she had been retired on medical grounds- Government attempting to enforce bond- whether estoppel by representation arises- whether bond deemed frustrated under the doctrine of frustration by illness or incapacity …

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF December 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
HMB Holdngs Ltd v The Attorney General et al
HCVAP 2010/007
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 05/12/11

MONTSERRAT
Reginald Simon v The Commissioner of Police
HCRAP 2011/001
Michel, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/12/11

Keithroy Lloyd v The Queen
HCRAP 2011/002
[Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 06/12/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Cedric Liburd v Eugene Hamilton et al
HCVAP 2010/017, 2010/018
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 05/12/11

SAINT LUCIA
Marguerite Desir et al v Sabina James Alcide
HCVAP 2011/030
Edwards, C.J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/12/11

Olvin Jn Baptiste v Inspector Peter Ermay [Ag]
MCRAP 2011/20
Edwards, C.J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/12/11
Magisterial criminal appeal – Criminal Code 2004 – Criminal Code (Amendment) Act 2008 – Criminal Procedure Rules 2008 – Whether a Magistrate has jurisdiction to amend an indictable charge to a summary one – Whether a Magistrate has jurisdiction to amend a charge after the limitation period for making a complaint for a summary offence has passed

Jessie St. Cyr v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/002
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 14/12/11
Criminal Appeal – Whether verdict unsafe and unsatisfactory – Evidence Act, Chapter 4.15 – Application of sections 55, 114, 115 and 136 of the Evidence Act – Whether there was need for an identification parade –Section 102 direction – Whether the probative value of the evidence outweighed the unfair prejudice to the defendant – Admission of previous representation of the deceased – Section 136 warning – Admission of evidence to establish motive

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
PQ v RS and another
HCVAP 2011/063
Blenman, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 06/12/11
Supplemental disclosure – Norwich Pharmacal Order – Norwich Pharmacal / Bankers Trust information – Challenges to findings of fact made by the learned trial judge – Whether the learned trial judge erred in finding that the first respondent had requested from its Professional Introducer everything that it was entitled to request in accordance with the order dated 14th September 2011 – Whether the trial judge erred in finding that the first respondent had asked the right questions in seeking to obtain information for the appellant

Cukurova Finance International Ltd et al v Alfa Telecom Turkey Ltd
HCVAP 2010/018, 2010/024
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 05/12/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
The Queen v Everton Welch
Criminal Case No ANUHCR 1994/0015
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 14/12/11

The Queen v Avie Howell et al
Criminal Case No ANUHCR 2010/0029-0030
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 16/12/11

Christiana Yearwood v Robin Yearwood
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0362
Michel, J.
Delivered: 08/12/11

Noreen Francis v Titus Francis
Claim No ANUHMT 2002/0044
Michel, J.
Delivered: 14/12/11

Kate Morris v Alphaeus Anthony et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0587
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/12/11

Lilouti Gooroodat v Imtiazul Tallim
Claim No ANUHMT 2011/0093
Michel, J.
Delivered: 21/12/11

Gary Nelson v The Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/00552
Remy, J.
Delivered: 13/12/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Marcus Romain v Joy Adrien
DOMHCV2009/0041
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 07/12/11

The State v Jachelena Lewis
DOMHCR 2011/029
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 05/12/11

GRENADA
George Jolly et al v Vallen Francois et al
GDAHCV 2010/0302
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 01/12/11

SAINT LUCIA
Robert Leotard of Reel Irie Ltd v Saint Lucia Air & Sea Ports Authority
Claim No SLUHCV 2011/0732
Belle, J.
Delivered: 08/12/11

General Investments Ltd et al v Joan Marquis
Claim No SLUHCV 2009/0398
Belle, J.
Delivered: 12/12/11

Bernard Prospere et al v Anthea Lynch et al and Margaret Lynch v Bernard Prospere et al
SLUHCV 2007/0619, 2008/1223
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 02/12/11

Morella Vitalis v Paul St Rose et al
SLUHCV 2006/0991
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 09/12/11

Gregor Juilan et al v Winfresh Ltd
SLUHCV 2010/0756
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 15/12/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Calvin Todman v Marguerite Hodge
Claim No BVIHCV 2009/0020
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 29/12/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF November 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
The Liquidators of Eurofed Bank Ltd v The Supervisory Authority
HCVAP 2010/051
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 21/11/11

GRENADA
Anthea de Bellotte v The Minister of Communications Works et al
HCVAP 2011/017
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/11/11

Janin Caribbean Construction Ltd v Ernest Wilkinson
HCVAP 2010/001
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Joan Isaac v Cecil Isaac
HCVAP 2009/013
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 21/11/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Kent Andrews et al v The Attorney General
HCVAP 2010/019
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 07/11/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Deshawn Stoutt v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/003
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Melvina Frett-Henry v Tortola Concrete Ltd et al
HCVAP 2008/024
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 21/11/11

Jeremy Outen John Milsom and David Standish v Mukhtar Ablayazov
HCVAP 2011/030
Judgment of the Court
Delivered: 10/11/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Robert Josiah v State Insurance Corporation
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0474
Michel, J.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Amos Charles v Tessa Charles
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0677
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

R Allen Stanford v The Liquidators of Stanford International Bank Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0149
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

La Tanya Hughes v Clement Hughes
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0455
Remy, J.
Delivered: 03/11/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Jeffery Charles v Lovette Charles
DOMHCV 2003/032
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 29/11/11

Cecilia Robin v The Attorney General et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2011/0060
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 16/11/11

SAINT LUCIA
Vernon James et al v Minivelle & Chastanet Ltd et al
SLUHCV 2010/1072
Belle, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

Angus Wayne Vitalis v Florentius St Marie
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0239
Belle, J.
Delivered: 17/11/11

Regina v Gaius McLauren
Criminal Case No SLUCRD 2011/0079
Cumberbatch, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

Regina v Clive McVane
Criminal Case No SLUHCRD 2010/0215
Cumberbatch, J.
Delivered: 30/11/11

Bank of St Lucia Ltd v Shery Heinis et al
SLUHCV 2004/0876
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 11/11/11

Treasure Bay (St Lucia) Ltd v The Gaming Authority et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2011/0456
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Ausbert Regis, Commissioner of Police v The Attorney General of Saint Lucia
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0497
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 21/11/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Linton Lewis v Colin Williams et al; Nigel Stephenson v Colin Williams et al; Vynette Frederick v Colin Williams et al; Patricia Chance v Colin Williams; Vynette Frederick v Sonya Young
High Court Civil Claim Nos. 19 of 2011, 20 of 2011, 21 of 2011, 76 of 2011, 100 of 2011, 115 of 2011
Thom, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Liao Chen Toh v Liao Hwang Hsiang
BVIHPB 93 of 2011
Joseph Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 29/11/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF October 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Antigua Power Co Ltd v The Attorney General et al
HCVAP 2009/006
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/10/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Nicholls Esprit et al v Speaker of the House of Assembly et al
HCVAP 2008/005
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/10/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Carleen Pemberton v Mark Brantley
HCVAP 2011/009
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 14/10/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
eChinaCash Inc. v Light Year Partners LLC and another
HCVAP 2010/032
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 19/10/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Troy Lewis v Constable Glendon Samuel et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0068
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 17/10/11

Omarra Small v Michael Laudat et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0012
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 17/10/11

SAINT LUCIA
The Queen v David Poleon et al
SLUHCR 2008/0060
Belle, J.
Delivered: 05/10/11

Hotel Chocolat Estates Ltd v Dasheen (1988) Ltd
SLUHCV 2009/1028
Belle, J.
Delivered: 20/10/11

Maurice Dantes v Cecile Bibiana Joseph
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0302
Taylor-Alexander, M.
Delivered: 25/10/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Daphne Alves v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2007/0306
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 24/10/11

The Queen v Calvin Rabsatt
Claim No. BVIHCR 2011/0034
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 24/10/11

JIPFA Investments Ltd v The Ministry of Physical Planning et al
Claim No. BVIHCV 2011/0040
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 31/10/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF September 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
A, B, C & D v E
HCVAP 2011/001
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 19/09/11

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Steadroy Benjamin v The Commissioner of Police et al
HCVAP 2009/023
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 19/09/11

GRENADA
Michael McIntyre et al v Grace Steele
HCVAP 2011/002
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/09/11

SAINT LUCIA
White Construction Co. Ltd. v DCG Properties Ltd
HCVAP 2010/022
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 26/09/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Chiverton Construction Ltd et al v Scrub Island Development Group Ltd
HCVAP 2009/028
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 19/09/11

Yukos CIS Investments Ltd et al v Yukos Hydrocarbons Investments Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/028
Redhead, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/09/11

Betteto Frett v Flagship Properties Limited
HCVAP 2009/026
[Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 27/09/11

David Swain v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/008
[Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 29/09/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Dean Jonas v James Rose
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0434
Marthurn, M.
Delivered: 21/09/11

Martin Roopnarine v Andrew Michelin
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0135
Michel, J.
Delivered: 19/09/11

Osbert Browne v Joycelyn Browne
Claim No. ANUHMT 2010/0128
Michel, J.
Delivered: 23/09/11

Eliza Paul v Donald Davis et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0432
Michel, J.
Delivered: 29/09/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Mcpherson Barber v Meyona Samuel
DOMHCV 2009/0101
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 12/09/11

Levie Maximea v Cpl. Nicholas Gordon et al
DOMHCV 2009/0054
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 12/09/11

The Development and Planning Corporation v Gifford Irish
DOMHCV 2009/0399
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 12/09/11

Roy Andrew v Susan Heitz et al
DOMHCV 2009/0410
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 15/09/11

Joseph Leblanc v James Cyrille
DOMHCV 2005/0089
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 15/09/11

Daniel Marie-Sante et al v Trans National Engineering Consultant Inc. et al
DOMHCV 2009/0438
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 15/09/11

Maria Yard v Paul Charles
Claim No DOMHCV 2002/0417
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 30/09/11

GRENADA
Henry Augustine v Gloria Augustine
Claim No GDAHCV 2001/0659
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 01/09/11

Peter Gernert et al v Egmont Development Inc. et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2010/0218
Henry, J.
Delivered: 30/09/11

Joel Horsford v The Attorney General of Grenada
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0423
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/09/11

Kishola Levine v Kenny Smart et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2007/0296
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/09/11

Grenada Technical and Allied Workers Union v Hon. Karl Hood
Claim No GDAHCV 2010/0370
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/09/11

SAINT LUCIA
Patrick Smith v Willy Vasson et al
SLUHCV 2008/0026
Belle, J.
Delivered: 28/09/11

Garnat George et al v Claudius Etienne
SLUHCV 2007/0698
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 01/09/11

Josephat Small v PC 711 Lester Byron et al
SLUHCV 2007/0866
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/09/11

Marcia Polius v The Attorney General
SLUHCV 2009/0178
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/09/11

Bryan Felix v The Attorney General et al
SLUHCV 2005/0941
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/09/11

Sonia Johnny v The Cabinet et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0931
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 26/09/11

Norma Louisien v Matthew Louisien
Claim No SLUHMT 2010/0008
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 29/09/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Olin Dennie v Cecil McKie et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2010/0206
Actie, M. [Ag]
Delivered: 30/09/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Elisabeth Robertson v Christina Washburn et al
Claim No. BVIHCV 2011/0158
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 23/09/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF August 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA
Cromwell Scott & Co Ltd v The Appeal Commissioners
GDAHCV 2010/0108
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 24/08/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Quorum Island (BVI) Ltd v Virgin Islands Environmental Council
BVIHCV 2009/021
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 12/08/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Ian Peters v Robert Spencer et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0445
Michel, J.
Delivered: 24/08/11

Ottis Payne et al v Zenroy Athill et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0506
Michel, J.
Delivered: 31/08/11

GRENADA
Clarence Ferguson v Stressman Thomas et al
Suit No GDAHCV 2004/0047
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 31/08/11

The Attorney General of Grenada v Seaview Corporation Ltd et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0229
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 29/08/11

SAINT LUCIA
Suzanna Isidore v Norton Gaspard et al
SLUHCV 1996/0400
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/11

Raoul Odlum v Catherina Jean Jacques et al
SLUHCV 2007/0015
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/11

Bay View Proprietors v Phillipe Chalano et al
SLUHCV 2009/0592
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/11

Christine Samuel v Bernard Serieux et al
SLUHCV 2008/0859
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 15/08/11

Alicia Francois v Moses Joseph et al
SLUHCV 2004/0611
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 15/08/11

Sabina Alcide v Marguerite Desir
SLUHCV 2007/0486
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/08/11

Sonia Hippolyte v Cletus Hippolyte
SLUHCV 2004/0078
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/08/11

Jessica Myers v David Myers
Claim No. SLUHMT 2009/0160
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 25/08/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Adina Garnes et al v Beatrice Gumbs and John Gumbs
High Court Civil Claim Nos 52 of 2009 & 53 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 10/08/11

Alan Straker v Marcia Stephens
High Court Civil Claim No 130 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 15/08/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
The Queen v Camillus Paris
Claim No. BVIHCR2010/0014
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 29/08/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF July 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
American International Bank Ltd v Landmark Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/003
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 04/07/11

SAINT LUCIA
Carlos Augustin v Uni-V (St. Lucia) Ltd
HCVAP 2010/044
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 27/07/11

Elias George v The Queen
HCVAP 2009/026
Rawlins, C.J. [Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 25/07/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Alfa Telecom Turkey Ltd v Cukurova Finance International Ltd. Et al
HCVAP 2010/018, 2010/024
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/07/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Sonia Grant v Maynard Williams
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0346
Remy, J.
Delivered: 20/07/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Layou Improvement Committee et al v Development and Planning Corporation
DOMHCV 2010/0127
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/07/11

Martha LeBlanc v Augustus Thomas et al
DOMHCV 2009/0296
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/07/11

Violetta Richards v James Richards
Suit No. DOMHMT 2007/0020
Stephenson Brooks, J.
Delivered: 29/07/11

GRENADA
Patrick Thomas et al v Thomas Real Estate Co Ltd. et al and Patrick Thomas et al v Crochu Beach Resorts Ltd et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2001/0652 & 2001/0653
Henry, J.
Delivered: 01/07/11

James Bristol v Andre Bernard
Claim No. GDAHCV 2009/0499
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/07/11

The Minister of Communications, Works et al v Anthea De Bellotte
Claim No. GDAHCV 2010/0310
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/07/11

George Donald Barclay et al v Hilda Clement
Claim No. GDAHCV 2003/0177
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 13/07/11

Ann Blackman v Kenny Forrester
Claim No. GDAHCV 2005/0469
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 13/07/11

MONTSERRAT
Lester Greenaway v David Taylor
Claim No. MNIHCV 2009/0007
Redhead, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/07/11

Nigel Lindsey v James Allen
Claim No. MNIHCV 2009/0021
Redhead, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/07/11

SAINT LUCIA
First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Eugene Nelson et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0197
Belle, J.
Delivered: 14/07/11

Godfrey Aurelien v Johny Chitolie
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0946
Belle, J.
Delivered: 21/07/11

The Queen v Aldrick William
Claim No. SLUCRD 2009/1690
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 05/07/11

The Queen v Claudius Edward
Case No. SLUHCRD 2009/0025
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 11/07/11

The Queen v Andrew Richardson
Claim No. SLUCRD 2009/0122
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 13/07/11

The Queen v Marlon Charles
Claim No. SLUHCRD 2007/1340
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 29/07/11

The Queen v Lenzie Polemis
Criminal Case No. SLUCRD 2008/1147
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 29/07/11

Albert Augustin v WPC 152 Bertie Ferdinand
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0647
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 26/07/11

SAINT VINCENT
Ulric Charles et al v Kristy Antoine et al
High Court Civil Claim No 37 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/07/11

Fletcher Goodluck v The Superintendent of Prisons et al
High Court Civil Claim No 125 of 2011
Thom, J.
Delivered: 20/07/11

The Incorporated Trustees of the Seventh Day Adventist Church v Delores Jordan
High Court Claim No 48 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/07/11

Irma Ollivierre v The Vessel "Bequia Express 1" et al
Claim No 472 of 2010
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 26/07/11

Jacqueline Chance v Jane Sutherland et al
High Court Civil Claim No 90 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 28/07/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Anju Dhar et al v Glenford David et al
Claim No. BVIHCV2009/0384
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 19/07/11

Eileen Papone et al v James Anthony
Claim No. BVIHCV2010/0113
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 28/07/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF June 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA
Anthony John v Antoine Monero
HCVAP 2009/026
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 21/06/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Elwardo Lynch v Ralph Gonsalves and BDS Ltd v Ralph Gonsalves
HCVAP 2009/002, 004
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 21/06/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Commercial Bank - Cameroun v Nixon Financial Group Limited
HCVAP 2011/005
Bennett, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 06/06/11

Jerry Martin v The Queen
HCRAP 2010/014
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 06/06/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Anton Tonge v The Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0167
Michel, J.
Delivered: 10/06/11

Steve Joseph v Leona Cornelius et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0045
Michel, J.
Delivered: 14/06/11

The Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda v Antigua Aggregates Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2005/0492
Michel, J.
Delivered: 17/06/11

Arvo's Ltd v Mark Anthony
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0336
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/06/11

In the Estate of Enrico Julian, Deceased
Claim No ANUHPB 2010/0123
Michel, J.
Delivered: 24/06/11

Garfield Christian v Ivan Hixon
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0083
Remy, J.
Delivered: 14/06/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Marcus James v Richard Royer
DOMHCV 2006/0098
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 30/06/11

Edison James et al v Speaker of the House of Assembly et al
Claim Nos. DOMHCV 2010/199 & 2010/200
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 10/06/11

Ronald Green v Petter Saint Jean et al and Maynard Joseph v Roosevelt Skerrit et al
Claim Nos. DOMHCV 006 of 2010 & 7 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 07/06/11

MONTSERRAT
Lilian Riley v Christopher Gerald et al
Claim No. MNIHCV 2004/0009
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 23/06/11

SAINT LUCIA
Ereen Archibald v Attorney General
High Court Civil Claim No 39 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Dawn Chance v James Chance
High Court Civil Claim No 91 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Rembert Thomas v Quarry Products Ltd
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/1693
Belle, J.
Delivered: 15/06/11

The Queen v Kevin Johnny
Criminal Case No. SLUCRD 2009/1268
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 20/06/11

The Queen v Sydney Prescod et al
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2002/1907, 1908
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 28/06/11

The Queen v Sydney Prescod et al
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2002/1907, 1908
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 29/06/11

Marie Clarke-Johney v Evariste Ambrose
SLUHCV 2008/0438
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 10/06/11

Victor Delices v Lindley Lubin et al
SLUHCV 2007/0431
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 27/06/11

Antonia Martial v The Public Service Board of Appeal
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0450
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 22/06/11

SAINT VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Ereen Archibald v Attorney General
High Court Civil Claim No 39 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Dawn Chance v James Chance
High Court Civil Claim No 91 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Christopher McMaster v Attorney General et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2009/00326
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 03/06/11

Gertrude Sewell v Ronald Providence et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2005/0215
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 03/06/11

Sharon Sprott v Corporal 599 Foster Scott et al
Claim No 377 of 2006
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 03/06/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
OBM Ltd v LSJ LLC
Claim No. BVIHCV2009/0451
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 03/06/11

JIPFA Investments Ltd v Natalie Brewley et al
Claim No. BVIHCV2011/0038
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 08/06/11

Mary Williams v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV2010/0048
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 22/06/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF MAY 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Kemba Swanston v Director of Public Prosecutions
HCRAP 2006/021
Edwards J.A.
Delivered: 17/05/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
Aubrey Smith v Calvert Fleming et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0050/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

Cora Richardson Hodge et al v. Attorney General of Anguilla et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0007/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

Lois Dunbar v Paul Webster
Claim No AXAHCV 0062/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

ANTIGUA
Paget Davis v Ruthlidge Crump et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0598
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 06/05/11

Janet Cochrane v Volmer Cochrane
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0480
Michel, J.
Delivered: 13/05/11

Estlyn Prophet v Royal Antiguan Beach Resorts Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0425
Michel, J.
Delivered: 16/05/11

George Purcell v George W Bennett Brysons & Co Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2006/0631
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/05/11

Terrance Sansom v Colin Turner
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0189
Michel, J.
Delivered: 25/05/11

Terrance Sansom v Colin Turner
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0189
Michel, J.
Delivered: 31/05/11

Maurice Joseph v Attorney General
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0547
Remy, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados Ltd v Oriel Walter
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0386
Remy, J.
Delivered: 11/05/11

Manuela Morganti v Silkincrest Investment Ltd et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0195
Remy, J.
Delivered: 17/05/11

Devon Brown v Neil Williams
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0636
Remy, J.
Delivered: 30/05/11


COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Edison Lewis v Davina Dangleben et al
DOMHCV 2004/0347
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

Anthony Commodore v Michael David
DOMHCV 2010/0241
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

GRENADA
First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2010/0098
Henry, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

Donna Neptune-Brathwaite et al v Richardson Pivotte et al
Claim No. GDAHCV 2002/0502
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

Kert Brizan v Director of Public Prosecutions
Claim No. GDAHCV 2010/0551
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

Albert St Bernard v Her Worship Karen Noel et al
Claim No. GDAHCV 2011/0052
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 12/05/11

SAINT LUCIA
Cecelia Deterville v Foster & INCE Cruise Services (St Lucia) Ltd
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0811
Belle, J.
Delivered: 23/05/11

Denis Mauricette v Eunice Mauricette
Claim No. SLUHMT 2010/0120
Belle, J.
Delivered: 31/05/11

The Queen v Alfredo Rodriguez et al
Claim No. SLUHCRD 2009/1108-1125
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 25/05/11

PC 707 Antoine v Eurious Eugene
Criminal Case No. SLUHCRD 2010/0761
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

CJ's Touring Service Ltd v Saint Lucia Air and sea Ports Authority
SLUHCV 2007/0265
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/05/11

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Brands Inc (St. Lucia)
Claim Nos. SLUHCV 2007/0640, 2008/0545
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 05/05/11

Charles Bernard et al v Joseph William et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2006/0397
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Friendship Bay Hotel Ltd v Braganza AB et al
High Court Civil Suit No 396 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/05/11

Paul Lewis et al v Canouan Resorts Development Ltd et al
SVGHVC 408 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 03/05/11

Frank DaSilva et al v Dr the Hon Ralph E Gonsalves et al
High Court Civil Claim No 371 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 13/05/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Clearlie Todman-Brown v Melvin Rymer
BVIHCV 2010/0049
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 11/05/11

The Queen v Shervon Anthony et al
Criminal Case No 10 of 2010
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 17/05/11

Ian Charles v The Board of Governors of the H Lavity Stoutt Community College
BVIHCV 2010/0049
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 30/05/11

Julian Willock v Attorney General et al
BVIHCV 2010/305A
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 24/05/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF APRIL 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA

The Beacon Insurance Co Ltd v Liberty Club Ltd
HCVAP 2010/029
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 07/04/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Ewart Bacchus v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/006
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 29/04/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA

The Queen v Gary Fleming
Criminal Case No 0015/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 12/04/11

ANTIGUA

Irma Smith et al v Omari Phillip
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0579
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 15/04/11

Govin Singh v Attorney General et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0268
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/04/11

Sally Ann Noel v Arthur Noel
Claim No. ANUHMT 1999/0098
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/04/11

Hazel de Freitas v Attley De Freitas
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0476
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/04/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Eslyne Rhyner v Ivan Moreau
DOMHCV 2004/0370
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/04/11

Keiron Pinard-Byrne v Comptroller of Inland Revenue
DOMHCV 2006/0292
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/04/11

GRENADA
Ashton Coomansingh v Jean Thompson
Claim No GDAHCV 2002/521
Henry, J.
Delivered: 08/04/11

SAINT LUCIA
The Queen v Leo St. Brice
Claim No. SLUCRD 2007/0646 & 647
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 15/04/11

Eudes Borne et al v National development Corporation
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0958
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 04/04/11

Patricia Yorkston v Tamarind Village Inc
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0465
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 06/04/11

Jennifer Prescott v Aldrick Parris et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0172
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 07/04/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Angella Richardson v Wayne Stephens
High Court Civil Suit No 18 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 18/04/11

Thelma Hall et al v Randolph Russell
High Court Civil Suit No 18 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/04/11

Wallace Dear v Carlita Cordice et al
Civil Suit No. 93 of 2007
Remy, J.
Delivered: 13/04/11

Millhawke Holdings (Bequia) Ltd et al v Stanley Dormieden et al
High Court Civil Claim No 301 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 19/04/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

The Queen v Keon Edwards
Criminal Case No 7 of 2009
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 07/04/11

The Queen v Richard Finnegan
BVIHCR 2011/0005
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 14/04/11

The Queen v Vernon Paddy
BVIHCR 2010/0020
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 27/04/11

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA

Bank of Nova Scotia v Appeal Commissioners
GDAHCV 2009/0533
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 30/03/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS

Jamoy Warner et al v Director of Public Prosecutions
HCRAP 2009/021/022
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 17/03/11

Vernon S Veira et al v Guy Mitchell et al
HCVAP 2010/021
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 22/03/11

Frantisek Stepanek et al v Aqua Investments Ltd et al
HCRAP 2011/002
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 23/03/11

SAINT LUCIA

Jada Construction Caribbean Limited v The Landing Limited
HCVAP 2009/011
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 08/03/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Gershon Robertson v Baldwin King
HCVAP 2008/020
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 14/03/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS

Bevern Smith v The DPP
HCRAP 2011/001
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 22/03/11

Westford Special Situations Fund Ltd v Barfield Nominees Ltd et al
HCRAP 2010/014
George-Creque, J.A.
Delivered: 28/03/11

Gerard Kraakman v Donna Sterling
HCRAP 2010/012
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 28/03/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Selwyn Charles v The Attorney General
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0069
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 02/03/11

Everette Jonas v Carlton Lewis
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0709
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 29/03/11

Caribbean Developments (Antigua) Ltd v Richard Sayer
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0560
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 30/03/11

Christopher Wheatley et al v Waterpoint Caribbean Homes Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0029
Remy, J.
Delivered: 09/03/11

Myrtle Looby v Geo Tech Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0092
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 11/03/11

Horizon Construction Ltd v Teddy Santos
Claim No ANUHCV 2005/0553
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/03/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Kieron Pinard-Byrne v Lennox Linton et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2003/0424
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 22/03/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS

Pina Panchal v Medical University of the Americas Ltd
Claim No. NEVHCV 2003/0096
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 28/03/11

Israel Paul v Julia Thomas et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2005/0221
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 28/03/11

SAINT LUCIA

Marcella de Freitas v Francis Lewis
Claim No SLUHCV 2009/0114
Belle, J.
Delivered: 28/03/11

The Queen v Claudius Joseph
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2009/0013 & 0014
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 17/03/11

The Queen v Sham Sanganoo
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2007/0653, 0669 & 0670
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 31/03/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Friendship Bay Hotel v Branganza AB et al
High Court Civil Claim No 396 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/03/11

Daniel Cummings v The Central Water and Sewerage Authority
Claim SVGHCV 20009/0124
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 31/03/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

Queen v Andre Penn
BVIHCR2009/0031
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 31/03/11

Mark Bailey v Betty Lou Bailey
Claim No. BVIHMT 2007/0015
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 02/03/11

Lesette Greene v Kenneth Greene
Claim No. BVIHMT 2007/0087
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 10/03/11

Betteto Frett v Owners and other persons interested in ship "Buckpasser Jeanneau 36" et al
Consolidated Claim Nos. BVIHAD2009/0008, 0009, 0010, 0011, 0012, 0015, 0017, 0019, 0023, 0024, 0025
Mitchell, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/03/11

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA

SLASPA v Leroy Mathurin et al
HCVAP 2008/035
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 21/02/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Casanki Quow et al v Commissioner of Police
HCRAP 2010/022
Rawlins, C. J.
Delivered: 21/02/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

The Commissioner of Police et al v Rudolph Maduro
HCVAP 2009/016
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 07/02/11

JSC BTA Bank v Fidelity Corporate Services Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/035
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/02/11

HIGH COURT JUUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
DRB Co Ltd et al v Carlton Lewis
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0189
Michel, J.
Delivered: 09/02/11

Montpellier Farm Ltd v Antigua Commercial Bank
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0243
Michel, J.
Delivered: 11/02/11

Josette Michael et al v Robert Benjamin Washington Jr
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0632
Michel, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

Bobb Persaud v Warren Headley-Hall
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0383
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 04/02/11

Everal Green v Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0185
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 04/02/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
The State v Emmanuel Azille
DOMHCR 2010/00361
Brooks, J.
Delivered: 07/02/11

Bernard Christopher v Roosevelt Skerrit
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0287
Brooks, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

Michel Williams v National Bank of Dominica
DOMHCV 2005/0002
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 03/02/11

Webster Shillingford et al v Norma Dalrymple et al
DOMHCV 2008/0308
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 11/02/11

Joseph George v Land Sales, Builders and Financial Ltd
DOMHCV 2007/0163
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 23/02/11

F. Christmas v Natioinal Fair Trade Organisation of Dominica et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2008/4668
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Joseph Leblanc v Attorney General et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2009/0254
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Staphine Emanuel v Clyde Lecointe
Claim No DOMHCV 2009/0166
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Wills Kelsick v Kenny Durand
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0128
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

Bernard Christopher v Roosevelt Skerrit et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0287
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

GRENADA
Janie Mason v George Mason
Claim No GDAHMT 2009/0004
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 01/02/11

Dorset Mitchell v Keith Gurley
Claim No GDAHCV 2005/0060
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 08/02/11

Kay Simon v Stephen Hardman et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0211
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 15/02/11

SAINT LUCIA

The Queen v Mitchel Joseph
Criminal Case No SLUCR 2008/0818
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 09/02/11

Rosemary Garraway et al v Aloysius Ferdinand
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0666
Belle, J.
Delivered: 03/02/11

Danny Severin v Attorney General
Claim No SLUHCV 2008/0973
Belle, J.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Barrie Wilkinson v Patricia Devaux
SLUHCV 2008/0637
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 17/02/11

Augustin Montoute et al v Victoire Simon et al
SLUHCV 2006/0905
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/02/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Dawn Chance v James Chance
High Court Civil Claim No 91 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 02/02/11

Rozemma Shallow v Wesley Mason
High Court Civil Claim No 15 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/02/11

Eric Ollivierre v Wynston Shabazz et al
High Court Civil Claim No 258 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 11/02/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Desmond Alphonso v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2010/0105
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 08/02/10

Andre Penn v The Director of Public Prosecutions
BVIHCR 2009/0031
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 22/02/10

Julian Willock v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2010/305A
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 03/02/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA

Earl Hunte v The Queen
HCRAP 2006/012
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 19/01/11

HIGH COURT JUUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA

Hulda Stanley v Lanval Phillips
Claim No AXAHCV 0054/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 13/01/11

Claimants A, B, C and D v Respondent E
Claim No AXAHCV 0063/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 26/01/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Rosy-Pierre Casimir v Zachary Casimir
Claim No DOMHMT 2009/0011
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 24/01/11

Huron Vidal v Merle Vidal
Claim No DOMHCV 2005/0002
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 25/01/11

Julius Carrierre et al v Jessie Bruney
Claim No DOMHCV 2008/0493
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 25/01/11

GRENADA
Nancy Jaleel v Michael John and Nancy Jaleel v Neville Elcock et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2002/0490 & 2003/0213
Henry, J.
Delivered: 14/01/11

Florence Williams v Grenada Cooperative Bank Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2007/0210
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 18/01/11

SAINT LUCIA

The Queen v Jesse Charles
Criminal Case No. SLUCRD 2009/0008
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 19/01/11

Heirs of Camselle St Catherine v Darius St Catherine et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2003/0444
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/01/11

Andre Alexander v St Lucia Golf Resort & Country Club Ltd
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0715
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/01/11

Bank of Saint Lucia et al v Madeline Couchman
Claim No. SLUHCV 2010/0389
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 14/01/11

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Malcolm Brayshaw
Claim No. SLUHCV 2005/0740
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 31/01/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

C. Emmanuel et al v R. Punnett et al and D. Hackshaw et al v O. Samuel et al
High Court Civil Claim No 364 of 2004
Thom, J.
Delivered: 19/01/11

C. Dillon Saul v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/020
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 25/01/11

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Carlton Bedminster et al v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/002, 003
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

Roger Naitram et al v The Queen
HCRAP 2006/005, 006, 008
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Michael Laudat v Danny Ambo
HCVAP 2010/016
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

SAINT LUCIA

Roland Browne v The Public Service Commission
HCVAP 2010/023
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

HIGH COURT JUUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA

Thomas P. Lydon et al v Barnes Bay Development Ltd et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0051/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 12/12/10

Sir Emile Gumbs v Sheffield Holdings Ltdl
Claim No AXAHCV 0090/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 13/12/10

Peter Adams v Ermine Adams-Plotkin
Claim No AXAHCV 0034/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 13/12/10

Gwenneth Webster v National Bank of Anguilla Ltd
Claim No AXAHCV 0098/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 22/12/10

Lineth Webster v Carolyn Gumbs
Claim No AXAHCV 0100/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/12/10

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Gerald Watt v FBO (2000) Antigua Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0254
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 02/12/10

Malaka Parker v First Caribbean International Bank Ltdl
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0748
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 20/12/10

Sandra George v Clement Samuel et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2004/0293
Michel, J.
Delivered: 13/12/10

Wingrove Jarvis v Mary Jarvis
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0099
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/12/10

Morris Gardner v Attorney General
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0745
Michel, J.
Delivered: 21/12/10

Joseph Hutchens v Jeffrey Cahall
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0099
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 16/12/10

GRENADA
Catherine Charles v Denham Peters
Claim No GDAHCV 2002/0469
Henry, J.
Delivered: 20/12/10

Grace Steele v Michael McIntyre et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2008/0251
Henry, J.
Delivered: 20/12/10

SAINT LUCIA
The Queen v Elian Phillip
Criminal Cases Nos. SLUCRD 2008/1216 & 1217
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 21/12/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

Grand Pacific Holdings Ltd v Pacific China Holdings Ltd
Claim No. BVIHCV 2009/389
Bannister, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 03/12/10

Royal Westminster Investments SA et al v Nilon Ltd et al
Claim No. BVIHCV 2009/389
Bannister, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/12/10

Cliff Williams et al v The Moorings Ltd
Claim No. BVIHCV 2009/0083
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 16/12/10

Loretta Frett v Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2007/0137
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 20/12/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Burton Riviere v Judith Durand
HCVAP 2006/013
Alleyne, C. J. [Ag.]
Delivered: 10/11/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Damian Hodge v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/001
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 10/11/10

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
Ashtrom Anguilla Ltd v Flag Luxury Properties (Anguilla) LLC et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0091/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Calefaccion Y Ventilacion SA DE C V v Flag Luxury Properties (Anguilla) LLC
Claim No. AXAHCV 0001/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Credit Suisse AG (Cayman Islands Branch) v Anguilla Masonry Products Co Ltd et al
Claim No. AXAHCV 0046/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

ANTIGUA
The Liquidators of Eurofed Bank Ltd v The Supervisory Authority
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0298
Michel, J.
Delivered: 26/11/10

James N George et al v Eldica Benjamin
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0271
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

Everton Cornelius v Allan Stevens et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2006/0234
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

Myrtle Looby v Dorothy Gittens
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0388
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
David Robin et al v Ulysses Auguiste et al
DOMHCV 2003/0141
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 25/11/10

Edison James v Speaker of House et al and Hector John v Speaker of House et al
DOMHCV 2010/0199, DOMHCV 2010/0200
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 22/11/10

The State v Deveril Benjamin
Case No 24 of 2010
Stephen-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 25/11/10

Kironie Sandy v The State
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0312
Stephen-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 26/11/10

GRENADA

Maria Harford v Gabriel Harford
Claim No. GDAHMT 1999/0112
Henry, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Patrick Thomas et al v Thomas Real Estate Co Ltd et al and Crochu Beach Resorts Ltd et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2001/0652, 2001/0653
Henry, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Ann Robertson v AG
DOMHCV 2004/0265
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 11/11/10

Liberty Club Ltd v Beacon Insurance Co Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2005/0409
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/11/10

Christopher Lord v Geraldine Pitt-Samuel
Claim No. GDAHCV 2006/0465
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

Catherine Maria St. Bernard v Olive Virginia McEwen
Claim No. GDAHCV 2008/0515
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Lindsay Fitz-Patrick Grant  v Glen Fitzroy Phillip et al
Claim No. SKBHCV 2010/00
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 04/11/10

Santos Perez et al v Minister of Nat. Security and Immigration et al
Claim No. NEVHCV 2010/0042
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 09/11/10

Leonne Skeete v Kenneth Skeete
Claim No. NEVHMT 2007/0022
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 11/11/10

Shuric Merchant v Tameika Williams
Claim No. NEVHCV 2009/0085
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 11/11/10

 

SAINT LUCIA
Prudence Robinson v Sagicor General Insurance Inc.
SLUHCV 2008/736
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 18/11/10

Samantha Anthony v Gregory Edward
SLUHCV 2008/0656
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/11/10

Patricia Edmund v Sr. Magistrate Floreta Nicholas
SLUHCV 2009/483
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/11/10

Robert Antoine v Johnston International Ltd
SLUHCV 2008/0975
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 30/11/10

Joanne Rowan et al v Bryan Stephen
Complaint No. 5 of 2006
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 17/11/10

Barbara Mc Quilkin et al v Aloysius Polius
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0119
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 25/11/10

1st National Bank St Lucia Ltd v Universal Fishing and Trading Co Ltd et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0998
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS

Vance Lewis v Joyce Lewis
Claim No. BVIHMT 2008/0062
Hariprashad-Charles, J.

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Jacqui Quinn-Leandro v Dean Jonas … election petitions
HCVAP 2010/018, 2010/019, 2010/020
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 27/10/10

Janice Reynolds-Greene v Community First Cooperative Credit Union
HCVAP 2008/027
Edwards, J. A.
Delivered: 25/10/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Maureen Peters v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/005
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 01/10/10

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Mathurin Jurgensen v Public Utilities Authority
Claim No ANUHCV 2004/0528
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Jack Scott et al v Wayne Robinson et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0056
Gonsalves, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/10/10

Andrea Stoelker et al v Bank of Antigua
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0197
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

The Supervisory Authority v The Liquidators of Eurofed Bank
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0298
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

C O Williams Construction (Antigua) Ltd v Jennings Building Production Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0484
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Geotech Co Ltd v Akindele Looby
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0578
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Akindele Looby et al v Dorothy Gittens et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0357
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Antigua Real Estates Ltd v Rupert Kenlock
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0041
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

The Public Utilities Authority v Lester Bryant Bird et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0353
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Geo w Bennett, Bryson & Co Ltd et al v Akindele Looby
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0722
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

The Public Utilities Authority v Shoppers Pharmacy et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0605
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Rupert Anthony v Patrice Browne et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0362
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Aziz Hadeed v Phillip Abbot
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0058
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Clive Oliveira v Attorney Geneal
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0608
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Annette Tuitt v ABI Bank Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0583
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/10/10

Anita Tobitt et al v Stanford Frederick
Claim No ANUHCV 2006/0026
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 13/10/10

Akeem Murraine v Antigua and Barbuda Hospitals Board
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0233
Michel, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Herman Esprit v Glenda Esprit
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0616
Michel, J.
Delivered: 28/10/10

ANGUILLA
Audrey Smith v Hilton Fleming
Claim No AXAHCV 019/1997
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Linda Tamn v The Fountain Beach and Tennis Club Ltd
Claim No AXAHCV 007/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 28/10/10

Lystra Ewen v Charles Sylvester Liddie
Claim No AXAHCV 0044/2007
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/10/10

Sylvanie Connor et al v Ileen Hodge-Richardson
Claim No AXAHCV 0043/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/10/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Lucy Paul v Emmanuel Joseph
Claim No DOMHCV 0172 of 2003
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 01/10/10

GRENADA
Dexter Smith v Attorney General et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2008/0328
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

Ronald Lessey v Garth Gellineau
Claim No GDAHCV 2007/0413
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

Bradford Noel v First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2004/0109
Henry, J.
Delivered: 18/10/10

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Bradford Noel
Claim No. GDAHCV 2004/0109
Henry, J.
Delivered: 18/10/10

Republic Bank (Grenada) Ltd v Alana Brathwaite et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2007/0345, 2007/0417
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Cedric Liburd v Eugene Hamilton et al
Claim No. SKBHCV2010/0020
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 13/10/10

SAINT LUCIA
Simone Jean Popo v John Popo et al and Victor Hippolyte et al v Simone Jean Popo
SLUHCV 2007/502, 2008/012
Georges, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Martin Devaux v Theresa Goddard et al
SLUHCV 2008/0405
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

Patrick Morille v Hermia Morille
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0285
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 27/10/10

1st National Bank of St Lucia Ltd v Universal Fishing and Trading Co Ltd
Claim No SLUHCV 2007/0998
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 29/10/10

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Elroy Arthur v T Michael Findlay
High Court Civil Claim No. 36 of 2009
Joseph, J.
Delivered: 04/10/10

Michelle Jones v The Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Port Authority
High Court Civil Claim No. 171 of 2009
Joseph, J.
Delivered: 13/10/10

Emmanual Johnson Chijioke v The Commissioner of Police et al and  Benjamin Fiifi Danquah v The Commissioner of Police et al
High Court Civil Claim Nos. 232 of 2010, 233 of 2010
Joseph, J.
Delivered: 21/10/10

Erlene Richardson v Helenor Williams et al
Claim No. SVGHCV 2009/044
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 18/10/10

Dr Ralph Gonsalves v Junior Bacchus et al
Claim No. SVGHCV 2009/0221
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 06/10/10

Angela Hinkson v Gibson Construction Ltd
High Court Civil Claim No. 149 of 2007
Thom, J.
Delivered: 05/10/10

Burton Williams v Elvineal Richards et al and Alexis Ollivierre v Andre Browne
High Court Civil Claim No. 133 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 13/10/10

Jomo Thomas v The Comptroller of Customs et al
High Court Civil Claim No. 331 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 20/10/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

GRENADA

Jude Jack v Attorney General et al
CLAIM NO. GDAHCV 2006/0351
Henry, J.
Delivered: 15/09/10

Reynold Benjamin et al v Blue Lagoon Real Estate Corporation
CLAIM NO. GDAHCV2004/0235
Henry, J.
Delivered: 15/09/10

Capital Bank International Ltd v Keith Mitchell et al
CLAIM NO. GDAHCV2008/0109
Henry, J.
Delivered: 23/09/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA

The Queen v Alexander Bonnet
CLAIM NO. SLUCRD 2008/0499
Benjamin, J
Delivered: 27/07/10